Justice for woman golfer in handicap dispute

WOMEN golfers must become less intimidating and more supportive of new players if they are to have any hope of arresting a rapidly declining interest in the game.

LORA FAIRCLOUGH

LORA FAIRCLOUGH

Four-time tour winner and Solheim Cup player Lora Fairclough highlighted the problem after she was informed of an incident at a Lancashire club in which a minority group of female members tried to retrospectively lower the handicap limit for a 36-hole competition.

In the firing line was a “rookie” who won a major prize only to be told later that her 32 ranking was too high – despite the maximum of 36 having being sanctioned by club officials – and demanded that her name did not appear on the honours board.

The objectors were eventually overruled by a considerable margin but the issue had already caused a good deal of controversy at the club and a certain amount of stress for the player.

Lora, who teaches at Preston Golf Club and recently stood down as Lancashire LGA coach, said: “I’m glad common sense has prevailed but the case in point is one of the reasons we are losing women golfers throughout the country at a vast rate of knots.

“We know it’s usually a minority group that cause these problems and that they also affect girls under 18 and juniors. It’s a totally unacceptable situation. The fact that this case involves an adult underlines what I consider to be a big issue.

“What we’re reaping today is an attitude that was prevalent about 10 years ago and we have to nip it in the bud. Otherwise, where are we going to be in another 10 years?

“I think many people will be shocked that it’s still going on.

“One of the reasons is down to certain women golfers who’ve been around for some time and don’t like change. And when someone comes along and does well in a competition this sort problem can arise.

“What would happen if a 36-handicapper and lifelong member, who had paid thousands of pounds in club fees, won her first board competition only to be told she was not eligible?

“We need to move forwards, not backwards.”

Lora’s feelings were endorsed by Shona Malcolm, a past Ladies’ Golf Union chairman, who said: “I despair at this incident. Ladies get so much adverse publicity and can do without this kind of situation.

“Of course the winner should be entitled to her prize. Everyone has a “purple patch” as they come down in handicap. It used to be a concern when the LGU introduced a ridiculous maximum handicap of 45 but it has generally settled down since the 36 limit has been reintroduced.

“I know of more than one beginner who has given up the game because of the attitude of their fellow lady members who were, of course, once beginners themselves. However we shouldn’t tar everyone with the same brush – most ladies are totally encouraging to newer and higher handicap players.”

Meanwhile, the case attracted a huge Facebook debate after Lora had posted her initial thoughts.

“I received fantastic support,” she added.

 

Advertisements

One response to this post.

  1. Thank you Lora, Shona Malcolm and David Birtill for highlighting the moral sense of this much talked about issue and bringing it into a wider arena. I would agree that some, but by far not all women, have a very short memory of the successes, Board prizes or otherwise, that came their way when they first started to play this fantastic game. Surely they must agree that this was the greatest encouragement they could ever receive, and inspire a love of the game that will last a lifetime.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: